Of Barclay’s Pallada & Boda

Published Post author

Leszek Kolankiewicz in his groundbreaking work Dziady resuscitated the Polish Pantheon. His ambitious book also tried to tackle the mention of the Goddess (or God?) by the name of Boda. That mention appears to occur only once in the 1538 (?) book Powieść rzeczy istej (see here) as part of a list of three idols: Lada, Boda, Leli:

Kolankiewicz thought that Boda appears in another work – Wacław Potocki’s 1697 translation of John Barclay’s “Argenis” (Argenida). Specifically, he mentions the following line:

O Palladzie ni dudu, ni słówka o Bodzie…

which roughly translates to:

Of Pallas [Athena] no mention, no word of Boda…

This would appear to put Boda on par with Pallas Athena (translated as Pallada into Polish in this case).

The problem with this interpretation is visible if we actually look at the same passage in print (on the left below):

All proper names in this Argenis translation are italicized. Pallas is italicized. But Boda is not. What is more, Boda, in the dative Bodze, appears at least twice more in the book (see on the rights side above), in each case without any italics.

In fact, a cursory review of Polish works suggests that Bodze was another manner of writing Boże, that is “God”. In other words, Potocki’s Bodze was referring to the Pallas Athene – the Pallada – mentioned immediately prior.

Although the Powieść rzeczy istej definitely lists Boda as among Lada and Leli, it is thus possible that the scribe or printer simply mistook the worshippers’ cries of Lado or Lada Boże.

A much more interesting question, however, is why Boda, or perhaps, Bod would even be used as the word for God in Polish and what that says about:

  • the derivation of the Suavic Bóg from Bhagga
  • the source of the Suavic word for “freedom: > swoboda
  • the connection between the Germanic Boden and the Suavic concept of Mother Earth

Thus, we have labodzić or lebodzić meaning “to complain” (to God) from the complaint la Boga! presumably (and also labieda or biadać meaning “to despair” possibly the source also of bieda meaning “poverty” – from “poor Boda” meaning “poor Boden” or soil leading to a poor harvest?)

Copyright ©2020 jassa.org All Rights Reserved

December 10, 2020

Jasień, Łado & the Earth Goddess

Published Post author

Perhaps the most intriguing and central mystery of the Polish Pantheon is the relationship between Jasień, Łado and the various fertility rites practiced in the Polish countryside. According to Długosz, Jasień/Yessa/Yassa is the Supreme God (Jove) while Łado is the God of War (Ares). This neatly but I think rather simplistically describes the functions of these two Deities.

I have instead close to zero doubt that Jasień the Rider is of the same origin as the Greek Iasion. The myth of Iasion and Demeter is the myth of the fertilization of Earth. But in the Polish version there is no vengeful Zeus equivalent. Why is this? It seems that the answer is provided by the Latvian historian of religion Haralds Biezais who notes that the the Latvian equivalent Deity – Ūsiņš – was often referred to as Dieviņš Ūsiņš or just Dieviņš (a diminutive of Diev which in ancient Baltic languages just meant “sky” and whose Suavic equivalent is dziw meaning “strangeness”). However, both Names refer to the same Deity and indeed Dieviņš is also used with Dieviņš Pērkons raising the suspicion that Pērkons and Ūsiņš were the same Deity. In other words, Dieviņš was just a title that the Greeks may have made into another Deity – Deus – or, ultimately, Zeus. As already noted in Polish piorun refers merely to the thunder but a similar word in Greek (piroúni) and Venetian (piron), refers to a “fork.” And, indeed, in Polish piorun may also refer to the “arrow” or a sky “stone.” In other words, piorun (Perun in Ukraine) is simply the tool of Jasień.

With that in mind, is there a room for Łado? Indeed, there is. Here the best guide is James Frazer whose study of the European fertility rites is the best by far to this day. It seems that the Polish agricultural society preserved the myth of the Sky God who came down to Earth and made life out of it. That Earth became impregnated with the “Son of God” Who then was born of the Earth. When? Around Christmastime, of course. At that point the Earth “dies” or falls asleep. That Son, in turn, arrives in strength and impregnates or “wakes up” the same frozen Earth again in the spring. His powers peak, also of course, in mid-summer and it is then that He is referred to as the warrior Łado. This Łado is a Son of Jasień and is, thus, the Jasieńczyk. Note also that the fertility rites start prior to mid-summer. In fact, that happens a little after the “drowning” or really melting of the Earth – the Marzanna. Soon after  the spring storms arrive and the Earth is impregnated. These rites happen to proceed full steam around Easter go through the Green Holidays (aka Pentecost) and culminate on Saint John’s Eve. Whether Łado passes away with the harvest is unclear although Frazer would speak of the Fertility God being sacrificed. If that were to happen, then the winter dziady holiday would seem the proper time for that. In any event, Łado is again, reborn at Christmas.

Łado is akin to Odin (the first – perhaps the first child of Jasień’s) who, after all, is also referred to on the continent as Wodin or Wodan or, even, Wadon.

Musings from Mannhardt

As already discussed, in Adam of Bremen’s description of the Uppsala temple we are reminded that the Top Swedish Deity may have been Thor, aka Asa-Thor whereas Odin was the God of War. Much as Łado, Odin too goes to sleep periodically. He is the first of the Aessir. Here we can compare the Polish word jeden meaning “one” but also pierwy meaning “first” or prawy meaning, physically, “right”.  That is, the right hand, perhaps, of Asa-Thor or perhaps of Yggdrasil (an ash or jesion). A right hand, however, is part of the body and is not a separate thing of itself. This interpretation seems rather appropriate for the Jasień-Łado relationship. (Note also that Asa-Thor seems to be a combination of perhaps an earlier (or only differently sourced?) Ass or Esus with Taranis/Turoń, the Bull (or, in Polish, the auroch).

Thus, in this view, Łado is a continuation of Jasień. In that sense He IS Jasień reborn.The new Jasień/Łado is reborn mid-winter and the cycle repeats itself. Does Łado have a Name other than Łado? It seems Długosz may have been onto something calling Łado the Polish Mars. There is a Suavic Deity with a similar Name and that is the Suavic Ares, that is Iarovit (Gerovit) Whose Eastern Name was Iarilo. In any event, the question about the exact relationship Father and the Son will likely be unanswered much as the question of Horus’ identity with Osiris has always remained  never fully explained.  It may also behooves to note here, as indicated above, that the Germanic Thunar – presumably the same as Thor – may be the same, in origin, as Wodan/Wadon. That woda means “water” in Suavic is also suggestive of the common origin of these Deities. 

In any event, Łado, like the Sun lives and dies and is reborn but Jasień after His first act of creation may be away somewhere else. In that sense Łado is the “local” caretaker, the Prometheus (compare with the Polish/Suavic promień meaning “sun ray”) the Svarozic of that other Svarog, that is of Jasień/Piorun.

Łado’s Earth consort is, of course, Łada. Why, of course? Well, because already in Luwian lada referred to the “beloved” or “consort” or “wife.” Thus, it seems, this too is a title. Note that Leto was impregnated by Zeus and Leto’s Doric Greek name is Lātṓ. Of course, lato means summer in Polish and other Suavic languages. Does Łada have a Name other than Łada? There are at least two possibilities here. The consort of Iarilo/Ares/Mars could be Marzanna. The Name Marha/Marcha is known from Sarmatian war cries. The term “march” refers to borderlands and so on. Another Name, however, may be Nyja. That is the Goddess of Nothing of Decay, the Pluto of the underworld as well as the Goddess of Death and of War. The Amazon  And yet, also the Mother, to whom we all go back to. Note that there were graves of the Przeworsk Culture where the deceased were placed in fetal positions. That would be indicative of going back to the “womb”. 

So was Łado , like Oedipus, sleeping with his Mother? Not necessarily. The relationship may well be that of siblings (certainly also offensive but Deities do not have many consorts to choose from). That is, Jasień may have been thought of like the Hebrew God as creating a local “Man” version of Himself. His Son Łado’s task is then to recreate Himself out of the Earth Who thus becomes His Consort.

What else remains to be said? I suspect that the myth of Iasion is the key here. It is also likely of similar origin to the myth of Jason and his golden fleece (the Sun?). In fact, it is likely that Iasion occasionally referred to as Iasius served as a model for the Christian Church Farhers who could not then resist but note the potential parallels of the story of Jesus of Nazareth to the preexisting myth of Jason/Iasion, a myth that was likely well known to the peasant class of Anatolia and Greece. It is perhaps for this reason that Yehoshua or Yeshua became Jesus and was effectively grafted onto the earlier story. That story, however, seems to be Indo-European or, perhaps, even pre-IE (note the myth of Isis-Osiris-Horus) dating back to the earliest memories of human civilizations.

Of course, this is not the only interpretation and many others have already been discussed here (for example, Łado as the child, but not the consort, of Mara/Marha/Marcha/Marzanna with Jasień being the Father).

Copyright ©2020 jassa.org All Rights Reserved

November 26, 2020

Aethicus Non-Ister Mu(r)sianus

Published Post author

I previously mentioned that Jordanes’ Lacus Mu(r)sinus was not likely to be identified with anything in the Danube delta or even anything in the Balkans generally. In fact, it may well have been Lake Constance (Bodensee). For that see here as well as here. This would be the appropriate place for the Western-most reach of the Suavs in Jordanes’ time and consistent with reports of the ancient Vindelici (supposedly Celts), nearby Noricans (claimed to be Suavs by Nestor’s PVL) and, of course, the also nearby Veneti.

However, I was doing some casual Aethicus Ister catching up when I saw the translator of that edition – Michael Herren – suggest another interesting possibility:

  • the East Austrian Neusiedlersee

Note that the name of that lake in antiquity was also similar to the name given to Lake Balaton. Either way, we are miles west of the Danube marshes.

Copyright ©2020 jassa.org All Rights Reserved

November 8, 2020

What Language Did the Goths Speak?

Published Post author

Simple answer: Gothic (which was a Teutonic language).

But the initial question has to be which Goths we are talking about.

Let’s listen to Jordanes talk about the Gothic conquests:

“Soon Geberich, king of the Goths, departed from human affairs and Hermanaric, noblest of the Amali, succeeded to the throne. He subdued many warlike peoples of the north and made them obey his laws, and some of our ancestors have justly compared him to Alexander the Great. Among the tribes he conquered were the Golthescytha, Thiudos, Inaunxis, Vasinabroncae, Merens, Mordens, Imniscaris, Rogas, Tadzans, Athaul, Navego, Bubegenae and Coldae. But though famous for his conquest of so many races, he gave himself no rest until he had slain some in battle and then reduced to his sway the remainder of the tribe of the Heruli, whose chief was Alaric. Now the aforesaid race, as the historian Ablabius tells us, dwelt near Lake Maeotis in swampy places which the Greeks call hele; hence they were named Heluri. They were a people swift of foot, and on that account were the more swollen with pride, for there was at that time no race that did not choose from them its light-armed troops for battle. But though their quickness often saved them from others who made war upon them, yet they were overthrown by the slowness and steadiness of the Goths; and the lot of fortune brought it to pass that they, as well as the other tribes, had to serve Hermanaric, king of the Getae. After the slaughter of the Heruli, Hermanaric also took arms against the Venethi. This people, though despised in war, was strong in numbers and tried to resist him. But a multitude of cowards is of no avail, particularly when God permits an armed multitude to attack them. These people, as we started to say at the beginning of our account or catalogue of nations, though off-shoots from one stock, have now three names, that is, Venethi, Antes and Sclaveni. Though they now rage in war far and wide, in punishment for our sins, yet at that time they were all obedient to Hermanaric’s commands. This ruler also subdued by his wisdom and might the race of the Aesti, who dwell on the farthest shore of the German Ocean, and ruled all the nations of Scythia and Germany by his own prowess alone.”

What was the lingua franca of this Gothic kingdom?

Now, let’s turn to Ammianus Marcellinus and his discussion of the conquests of the Alans, neighbors to the Goths:

“On the other side of this river [Tanais/Don] the Halani, so called from the mountain range of the same name, inhabit the measureless wastes of Scythia; and by repeated victories they gradually wore down the peoples whom they met and like the Persians incorporated them under their own national name. Among these the Nervii inhabit the interior of the country near the lofty, precipitous peaks nipped by the north winds and benumbed with ice and snow. Behind these are the Vidini and the Geloni, exceedingly savage races, who strip the skins from their slain enemies to make clothing for themselves and coverings for their horses in war. On the frontier of the Geloni are the Agathyrsi, who checker their bodies and dye their hair with a blue colour — the common people with a few small marks, but the nobles with more and broader spots of dye. Beyond these are the Melanchlaenae and the Anthropophagi, who according to report lead a nomadic life and feed upon human flesh; and because of this abominable food they are left to themselves and all their former neighbours have moved to distant parts of the earth. And so the entire north-eastern tract, until one comes to the Seres, has remained uninhabitable. In another part of the country, near the abodes of the Amazons, the Halani mount to the eastward, divided into populous and extensive nations; these reach as far as Asia, and, as I have heard, stretch all the way to the river Ganges, which flows through the territories of India and empties into the southern ocean. Thus the Halani (whose various people it is unnecessary now to enumerate) are divided between the two parts of the earth, but although widely separated from each other and roaming over vast tracts, as Nomads do, yet in the course of time they have united under one name, and are, for short, all called Halani because of the similarity in their customs, their savage mode of life, and their weapons. “

Even assuming many of these are concoctions of a man schooled in Herodotus and the classics, the message of an Alanic multi-ethnic “empire” is unmistakable.

And then what happened as the Huns attacked?

“The Huns, then, having overrun the territories of those Halani (bordering on the Greuthungi) to whom usage has given the surname Tanaïtes, killed and plundered many of them, and joined the survivors to themselves in a treaty of alliance; then in company with these they made the more boldly a sudden inroad into the extensive and rich cantons of Ermanaric… After his demise Vithimiris was made king and resisted the Halani for a time, relying on other Huns, whom he had paid to take his side. But after many defeats which he sustained, he was overcome by force of arms and died in battle. In the name of his little son, Viderichus, the management of affairs was undertaken by Alatheus and Saphrax, experienced generals known for their courage…During these days also Vithericus, king of the Greuthungi, accompanied by Alatheus and Saphrax, by whose will he was ruled, and also by Farnobius, coming near to the banks of the Danube, hastily sent envoys and besought the emperor that he might be received with like kindness.” 

Now, Alatheus, probably, and certainly Saphrax, are not Gothic names. Vithimiris is most likely a Suavic name even if Viderichus is Germanic. Farnobius is likely neither.

Once the Huns and Alans overcame the Ostrogoths this whole menagerie of nations settled in Pannonia. What was the relative size of the various populations?

Well, we know both from Jordanes and from Ptolemy (and Tacitus to some extent) that the Veneti were a multitude or roamed vast distances.

So what language did these people assembled under Attila speak?

Let’s turn to Priscus (via Jordanes):

“instead of grain we were given millet; instead of wine, a drink grown locally called medos. The servants following us also brought millet and supplied a drink made from barley, which the barbarians call kamon.”

And some more from Jordanes:

“When the Huns had mourned him [Attila] with such lamentations, a strava, as they call it, was celebrated over his tomb with great revelling.”

Otto Mänchen-Helfen did not mince words when he wrote that Vasmer’s (and Schwartz’) objection to a Suavic etymology of strava (should have been sutrava) “cannot be amen taken seriously.” He also pointed to Popovic’ (in Sbornik Radova vizantoloshkog instituta 7 (1961)) and, earlier, Kotliarevskii’s (1863), Nehring’s (1917) and Trautmann’s (1944) support for the Suavic etymology.

Mänchen-Helfen also concluded that kamon/kamos was the earlier Pannonian kamum (citing Julius’ Africanus’ “Embroideries” and Diocletian’s Edictum de Pretiis) and that medos was either Germanic or Illyric. Both of these words also have Suavic cognates (or maybe etymologies?).

As another side note, Mänchen-Helfen also proposed that the Sclavenes/Venethi reference in Getica that mentions the Vistula (as opposed to Viscla) was the original Cassiodoran version (not Jordanes’). Notably that is the passage that speaks of the Venethi possessing vast swaths of territory seemingly north of the sources of the Vistula.

But let’s get back to the argument:

Who fought the Goths after the demise of the Huns? Jordanes tells us Skiri, Suavi, Sarmatians, Gepids and Rugi – another motley crew of nations. What language did they communicate in?

As already noted, Thursday was labeled the “fifth” day in Gothic (as reconstructed *pintadags or *paintedags. Again, compare this with the Polish piątek – meaning “Friday”. And again, Friday is reconstructed as *pareinsdags (but also paraskaiwe) which suggests a curious similarity to Piorun/Perun. Compare this with the Polabian Perĕndan for Thursday (Thor’s day).

And there are many other words in Suavic that ring of Gothic-Suavic connections: gniew (“anger” but compare with “knife” and Gniew(ko) with Cniva) or sługa (notwithstanding Brueckner, > słuchać?).

It seems to me then that it was the Goths, at first on their own and then driven by the Huns that spread the Venetic, that is, Suavic, population around much of the Balkans. It would not therefore surprise me that the vast majority of the “Goths” (as in those people conquered by the Goths and who served in the Goths’ armies) actually spoke the Suavic lingua franca.

Copyright ©2020 jassa.org All Rights Reserved

October 16, 2020

Pantheonic Confusions

Published Post author

Here are some interesting connections between the name of the supreme Deity and various numeral systems.

odin/odyn/jeden – Suavic numeral one
Odin – head of the Icelandic pantheon

diš, – Sumerian numeral one
Dyḗus – reconstructed form of the head of the Indo-European pantheon
Jasień/Yassa/Yessa – head of Polish pantheon

išten – Akkadian numeral one
Isten – God in Hungarian
istnieć – to exist in Polish

In fact, in some cases we seem to have astral bodies/Deities or physical phenomena (another example: day <> dzień <> dan <> lord > Daniel <> Danuvius <> Adonis <> Odin) almost explicitly used as numerals. All this probably indicates that religions spread much earlier than we had thought and that cross-civilizational religious proselytization happened relatively frequently. Here are some interesting potential connections (of course, all of this, while interesting, is highly speculative).

Then there are the similarities between the Polish/Ukrainian Divinities, the Greek and some version of the “Scandinavian” pantheons. Here we have three types of names:

  • As/Es – Jasień (also As, Esus)
  • Ad/Od – Łado (also Wodan, Wadon, Gotan, Odin)
  • Tor/Tar/Tur/Ar? – Turoń, Taran (also Thor, Taranis, Piorun?, Iarilo?)

Further, the As and the Tor seem related and may comprise a single Divinity (compare with Asa-Thor/Ása-Þórr).

These Names reflect the following portfolios:

  • sky
  • thunder
  • vegetation/fertility

but also and separately:

  • war (Łado)

They seem to have evolved into different directions. The Thunder God sometimes seems separate from the Sky God.

At other  times the Thunder God is the Sky God and then there is a separate Being – His Son or maybe Avatar that is responsible for the earthly activity such as war or fertility vegetation. The Polish Jasień is the Sky God but Łado is also a Jasieńczyk (son of Jasień?, emissary?, avatar?) responsible for war or vegetation/fertility.

Although Odin is the head of the Scandinavian pantheon, this is really the late Icelandic version. Odin may have usurped the throne of Thor (Tyr?). Specifically, in Adam of Bremen’s Uppsala temple description, it is Thor who is responsible for thunder but also vegetation (which makes sense) whereas Wodan sits at Thor’s side responsible only for war. Thus, it would be Asa-Thor/Ása-Þórr that is responsible for crops/harvest. And, we have asans that is Gothic for “harvest.” This, in turn, is cognate with the Suavic jesień (fall) or wiosna (spring).

Eventually, during some downgrade the same name began to be associated with weakness, stupidity, however. Thus, we have an “ass” and “idiot” and “donkey” and so forth. I assume (at the risk of looking like an ass) that the Nynorsk aden meaning “angry”, “noisy,” “nasty” (?) goes back to the Latin name for a donkey.

Even here the Tar- and As- connection may remain perhaps > Luwian tarkasna and Sumerian anšu (“weak” compare with dannu “strong” – compare this with latter word with Odin/Adonis).

It is interesting that Wodan was spelled Wadon on occasion. It is also interesting that this is pronounced Vadon whereas the Polish Łado is pronounced Wado. Similarly we have the German word for water – pronounced Vasser – which in English is, of course, water.

Although Wodan/Wadon is supposedly translated as the “furious” (Wut meaning anger, fury), it is curious that the Suavic offers multiple possible explanations/etymologies of the name:

  • odin/odyn/jeden – number one; compare also with odyniec – the lone boar
  • Wado/Lado/Łado – the lover/beloved (compare that with the lada – in Lycian meaning the same for a female and preserved in East Suavic (translated as Gattin into German; compare this with the male Gatte – in each case meaning “spouse”; compare further with Godan or gody/godzić – the latter meaning to work towards an agreement/reconcile or the Russian god meaning “year”)
  • Wodan – lord of water – woda – pronounced voda (szczoby nas oczystyw – “so that he should cleanse us”)
  • wódz or wojewoda (pronounced voyevoda – the Heerzeer > Herzog – księżyc but not König) or wodzin – leader – compare this with the reconstruction of *Wōdanaz – a man leading along the waters/rivers?

Thus, we have two functions but perhaps the same Deity. Is this because of trying to reconcile multiple tribal pantheons or Divinities?

We know in the East Perun/Piorun was worshipped – was Perun a Thunder God? It seems yes but also a Sky God and a Vegetation/Fertility God. There is a not too ancient song that was collected by the folklorist Oleksiy Ivanovych Dey (Олексій Іванович Дей) in his 1963 volume “[Ukrainian] Games and Songs: Spring-Summer Poetry of the Work Year” (Ігри та піснівесняно-літня поезія трудового року). In that book he notes the following words:

Гей, око Лада,
Леле Ладове,
Гей, око Ладове,
Ніч пропадає,
Бо око Лада 
З води виходить,
Ладове свято
Нам приносить.
Гей, Ладо!

А ти, Перуне,
Отче над Ладом. 
Гей, Перуне,
Дай дочекати
Ладе купала.
Гей, купала!
А кум і кума
— У нашу хату.
Гей, кум і кума!

Солод ситити,
Медок хмелити.
Гей, кум і кумо,
Щоби і внукам
То пам’ятати
Гей, кум і кумо!

Interestingly, here we have Perun called the “Father of Lado” (also Lado is the Sun or, rather, the Sun is the eye of Lado). But if Perun is Thor and if Thor was the supreme Divinity in Sweden (the home of the Varangians) and Odin was the War Divinity on the side of Thor, then here is another reason as to why Łado/Lado may be Odin (aside from the Lado/Wado linguistic similarities). Of course, whether this represents any actual remnant of ancient beliefs is, given the late recording of the same, at the very least uncertain. Nevertheless, the words are curious and may express the belief of a certain Duality.

That Thor/thunder is Piorun/Perun is obvious and confirmed in other ways. In Polabian Perĕndan refers to Thursday which is direct translation of the same. Curiously, Thursday was labeled the “fifth” day in Gothic (as reconstructed *pintadags or *paintedags – compare this with the Polish piątek – meaning “Friday”; presumably because Sunday was the first day) BUT the Gothic “Friday” is reconstructed as *pareinsdags which suggests a curious similarity to Piorun/Perun (though recorded as paraskaiwe – from the Greek “preparation” [for the Sabbath/Sunday]) .

Anyway, we also have this song (also relatively recently recorded though the recording is older than the above):

Oj, Łado, Łado, oj dana dana,
idem do pana, do pana Wodana,
szczoby nas oczystyw i nas błohosławyw

Whether the “dana” – the obviously female person being “given away” to Łado has anything to do with the Irish Mother Goddess Danu – the mother of the Tuatha Dé Danann is another intriguing question. (Éire may have been the name giver to Ireland and a Goddess but do not forget that the Name of the emerald, shall we say green, isle also suggests a connection to the Suavic Jaryło/Iarilo).

We can subdivide this to say that the Sky and Thunder/Lightning and perhaps Fertility/ Vegetation is the domain of a Sky God that is separate and supreme from the other God that visits the Earth. That other “local” Divinity that watches us through His Great Eye (the Sun). That Deity may be a relation or just a local caretaker. He is responsible for the actual fertilization of the Earth (but only after the Supreme Deity pounds the Earth with thunder and lightning?) as well as, perhaps, for water. In some cultures He may have been relegated to a pure “war” role (Wodan but also compare Iarilo/Gerovit (fertility but also war) with Mars/Ares (war but earlier perhaps fertility). What about the Other Eye – the Moon? Well, remember Odin had one Eye… The other was not working so well.

Alternatively, the Polish Jasień is the curious case of, perhaps, both of these functions embedded in one Being as He seems to appear both as the supreme Deity (Długosz) but also as the Visiting Deity. It’s not clear from the Polish songs whether Łado is the Father, the Son or, in fact, Both – like an avatar. Perhaps the best way to say this is that Odin is the first Ass.

Is the Polish version, therefore, the simpler (“original”?) myth where the Sky God descends from the Sky to fertilize the Earth (being both Jasień and Łado – meaning beloved – of the Earth Goddess? Is the Earth Goddess Jasień’s Łada? Is She the Goddess of Earth but also of War as well as Decay/Death called Marha or, later, Marzanna? Does She then combine the functions of the later Athena and Demeter? For this interpretation, see also the discussion of Jason below. But for another interpretation read further down.

Perhaps the most interesting Greek myth from the perspective of Polish mythology is the Iasion/Demeter myth which also introduces Zeus as the jealous overlord (in the myth Zeus is Iasion’s father) who strikes down Iasion (but then maybe Iasion survives).

Indeed, we also have an Armenian legend of Gisenke and Demetr where Zeus is nowhere to be found. Was then Zeus a new Divinity that struck down the prior Sky God? Perhaps a new Divinity introduced by new invaders? Indo-Europeans or a particular type of Indo-Europeans?

Iasion has a sister whose name is Harmonia (which, of course, is easily connected with harmony – order – or, in Polish ład – the marital harmony of the marriage contract?). Iasion also has a brother Dardanus (the names Darda and Derda are present at high numbers and frequencies in Poland, to a lesser extent Greece and, the first, in high numbers though not frequency in India). There is also an interesting connection to Jason and Athena (remember Minerva the Roman Athena Lada may have been called Lada). For that see also here.

What this suggests is that Lado was not originally a separate Deity from Jasień. What it also suggests is that Jasień-type Divinity may have at some point been downgraded.

The anšu was replaced by the dannu or Jasien (also recall Janus) by Lado.

There seems to exist another myth overlapping here, a myth that involves Jason and Athena (Minerva/Lada?) and Jason’s trip to the underworld (the Sun’s going beyond the horizon and the rebirth of the same but necessarily different (I mean how can it be the same if it came from the opposite direction!) Sun from the East). This myth involves a dragon in the bowels of the Earth. That dragon is, in Greek myth, referred to as… Ladon. Ladon in that version of the myth is slain but not by Jason whose party arrives after Ladon had already been mortally wounded but by Hercules (Thor?).

And yet, there is that Vatican vase on which Athena is seen watching (?) Jason be in effect disgorged by a dragon. No one else is in the picture…

I leave aside the fact that Athena would correspond to the Suavic genitive of Odina (“of Odin” or Odin’s) and that Athena is the daughter of Zeus and that in many Polish folk songs, Jasien steals his Lady from her father.

I too leave aside the “dragon’s teeth” myth which also touches Jason, of course.

Perhaps it is the case that, at some ancient point in time, an Od/Ad replaced the As as the head of a pantheon. In some cases that Od/Ad became the head of the pantheon and the As was downgraded to a minor role. In other cases, Odin/Lado was taken into the pantheon but remained secondary warrior deity like Mars (Polish or Swedish).

Perhaps, in the alternative, an Odin-like person functioning as a Divine King, claimed to be the Jasień (something like a Second Coming) on Earth. 

That the As has an interesting history, we can also guess from the obvious connections of Iasion’s with Jesus (the greatest “story” ever told? – by the brilliant Saul of Tarsus).

However, another way of looking at this is to say that the Son of God – Łado – is the local Caretaker/Overseer for the Earth. Perhaps, He is the Lord of the Sun (and Moon?) but not much further? A Prometheus-like figure that brings fire and knowledge to humans (whether permitted or not?). Perhaps He also copulates with “Mother Earth” – the truly local Divinity – something that the Jasień in the Sky Further Out does not approve of. Of course, this also brings up the myth of Oedipus (Oed- prefix as suggestive?). Further, it is curious that Ladas of Argios was such a fast runner as was the later Ladas of Aegium – kind of like the Sun in the Sky. And the Argios Ladas died from exhaustion after the race – again, kind of like the Sun at the end of the day. This also brings up the race (in chariots?) against Chors (the Moon?) in The Tale of Igor’s Campaign. Were the Sun and the Moon (or their drivers) perceived by the ancients as participating in some type of a relay race across the Sky?

Here are some interesting connections between the different Sky Gods/Demi-Gods:

Of course, there are other connections. Ugaritic Dgn and Dagon may have been fertility gods. Indeed, there is the Hebrew word for grain dāgōn. That, of course, brings to mind the Giving God – Dadźbóg – that is also, of course, associated with the Sun. In fact, Dag and Bog (bhagga) may mean the same thing that was stitched together in some cross-cultural setting. It is also cognate with day and dzien and so too with Odin/Lado.

Note too that the Russian lake Ladoga – if read as a Suavic genitive/possessive – could be interpreted as Ladog’s (Svarog and Ladog?). Of course, no one reads it that way but who knows, maybe scholars ought to think about that possibility.

There is another possibility here. The Marzanna may well be just the personification of death and decay – mara – the lifeless Earth. In other words, have we been beguiled and led astray by the “Mother Earth” or “Goddess” idea? Iasion has a sister – Harmonia. Is Athena that Harmonia? In this version the Divine Twins are Male and Female – Jasień and Łada. In some Polish legends there is talk of the Moon and His Morning Star. (Or maybe Jasień cheated on the Sun – Łada – with the Morning Star (Zorza?) akin to Jason cheating on Medea?). To be fair, the Iasion-Harmonia <> Jasień-Łada comparison raises the question of who here is Dardanus?

Almost forgot to mention that Oleksiy Ivanovych Dey collected the above song from the Ukrainian town of Yasen (perhaps near today’s Ivano-Frankivsk):

Copyright ©2020 jassa.org All Rights Reserved

September 16, 2020

Revisiting the Polish Pantheon

Published Post author

You can view some theories on the nature of the Polish Pantheon here and here. I confess we are unlikely to have more answers without further review of all that is available on the topic. However, I believe that the three most likely versions of the myth go something like this…


Father & Mother
Children


Jasień the Sky God is the Didis Łado of His Łada (but maybe Didis Lela), that is, the Female Goddess (Mother Earth?). She is the protector of Jasień’s while He is with Her. The other Deities are the Leli, their offspring (from the Jasień-Łada/Lela union):

  • Pogoda (covering good weather and happiness)
  • Dziewanna (responsible for the hunt and the wilderness),
  • Marzanna (covering the sea, death and the cold generally), and
  • Żywie (the God of Life)
  • potentially Lela (covering fertility unless that Divinity is the same as Łada)

Perhaps the first Three are the Three Zorze, Zarzyce that is the Zarze Zarycze Trzy Szyestrycze Polonice (see here).

The Nothingness out there is Nya which can prevail if Jasień is not periodically rekindled over and over again.


Father Star Tree
Son & Daughter
Children


Another version is a little bit different. Jasień is the Eternal Tree-Star (gwiazda being just another name for a tree – gwozdgozd – see here). Jasień is also the Sky God, of course.

The female Goddess Didis Lela (potentially, though not necessarily, also aka Łada) and the male Didis Łado (the Jasieńczyk or Son of Jasień) are the Children of Jasień’s and the guardians (both) of Jasień’s who rekindle Jasień with every cyclical pairing.

The Children (the Leli) of the now Lela-Łado union are the same as above.

The Nothingness out there is Nya which can prevail if Jasień is not periodically rekindled over and over again.


Father & Mother
Son & Other Children


The other version is yet different. Here we have Jasień the Sky God Himself as the consort of the female Goddess (perhaps Lela; potentially, though not necessarily, also aka Łada).

Łado is the Hero of Jasień’s that guards Jasień’s descent to Earth to rekindle Mother Earth. He is the First of the Children (Leli of the slightly different Jasień-Łada/Lela union) with the Others being the same as above. He is the protector of Jasień’s and God of War.

Nya, once again is the nothingness.


Note that in each case the absolute key are the fertility rites that preserve the Jasień Family.

At least that’s my current take.

Copyright ©2020 jassa.org All Rights Reserved

August 22, 2020

Collages

Published Post author

It’s really great to see some of the calligraphy from medieval manuscripts that anyone can nowadays pull up and enjoy  :-). This is from Cambridge’s Corpus Christi College collection.

Copyright ©2020 jassa.org All Rights Reserved

August 10, 2020

Wārsawa

Published Post author

Interestingly, in Luwian, we have the following:

  • wārsa – water

So.. is Warszawa, a Luwian name?

Curiously, they also have the Sun as tiwaz and the Moon as *armas (the last is a reconstruction).  Of course the Vandalic Froia arme means “Lord have mercy” but the arme refers to “mercy” (see also “arm” meaning poor in German).

All of these as per the Swadesh List.

For another Anatolian reference see here for a Lycian > Suavic explanation of Lada.

Copyright ©2020 jassa.org All Rights Reserved

August 10, 2020

Sources on Suavic History

Published Post author

I am reducing the time on this website. Much already has been written. If there are other interesting things that come to view, I will try to write about them but it will not be a frequent affair – best guess is perhaps once a month.

So, in order to encourage the readers to look at various sources on Suavic history I include a little list of various Polish & other Suavic compendia on the subject.

Kails!


The first book treating Suavic antiquity has to be Safarik’s “Slavic Antiquities”. Niederle then tried to improve upon that but did not really succeed in my view.

A pure listing of sources was put together by Marian Plezia in Najstarsze świadectwa o Słowianach and then in Greckie i łacińskie źródła do najstarszych dziejów Słowian.

Then we had Tadeusz Lewicki put together  list of Arab sources on Suavs. His Źródła arabskie do dziejów Słowiańszczyzny came out in four volumes (in Polish):

  • volume I  (1956) on:
    • AL-AHTAL
    • AL-HUWĀRIZMĪ
    • IBN HURDĀDBEH
    • AL-GĀHIZ
    • KITĀB AL-MAHĀSIN WA ’L-ADDĀD
    • AL-FARGĀNĪ
    • IBN QUTAJBA
    • AL-BALĀDURĪ
    • AL-JA‘QŪBĪ
  • volume II part I (1969) on:
    • IBN AL-FAQĪH, KITĀB AL-BULDĀN
    • IBN AS-SAGĪR, CHRONICLE OF TĀHERTU
    • IBN WAHŠIJA, KITĀB AL-FILĀHA AN-NABATĪJA
  • volume II part II (1977) on:
    • IBN ROSTEH, KITĀB AL-A‘LĀQ AN-NAFĪSA
  • volume III (1985) (with Anna Kmietowicz & Franciszek Kmietowicz) on:
    • IBN FADLĀN, KITĀB (from the Mashad manuscript)
  • volume IV (1988) (with Maria Czapkiewicz & Franciszek Kmietowicz)
    • indices to prior volumes

Finally, you had Urszula Lewicka- Rajewska continue where Lewicki left off with Arabskie opisanie Słowian. Źródła do dziejów średniowiecznej (2004).

Importantly, Professor Lewicki also managed (with Franciszek Kupfer) to publish a compendium of Jewish sources in Źródła hebrajskie do dziejów Słowian i niektórych innych ludów środkowej i wschodniej Europywyja̜tki z pism religijnych i prawniczych XI-XIII w. 

During the same time Gerard Labuda collected some Scandinavian sources, focusing on Poland, in his Źródła, sagi i legendy do najdawniejszych dziejów Polski. This volume includes

  • King Alfred’s Orosius including its Geography
  • Wulfstan travels
  • Ohthere’s travels
  • Widsith (including Gothic references)
  • Hervarar saga ok Heiðreks (Gothic references)
  • Song of Roland & Its Suav mentions
  • Sources for the Tale of Walgierz the Strong

A more thorough series on Suavic history came out (and continues to come out) courtesy of Slavica (which is a publication of the Suavistic Insitute of the Polish Academy of Sciences (Instytut Slawistyki Polskiej Akademii Nauk) under the title Testimonia najdawniejszych dziejów Słowian.

This series includes the following issues of Slavica;

The Greek Writers’ Series:

  • volume I (introduction/bibliography?)
  • volume II (Slavica issue 63) Pisarze z V–X wieku (“Writers of the V-X century”)
  • volume III (Slavica issue 103) Pisarze z VII–X wieku (“Writers of the VII-X century”)
  • volume IV (Slavica issue 106) Pisarze z VIII– XII wieku (“Writers of the VIII-XII century”)
  • volume V (Slavica issue 127) Pisarze z X wieku (“Writers of the X century”)
  • volume VI (Slavica issue 137) Pisarze wieku XI (“Writers of the XI century”)

The tables of contents for II, III & IV are here:

Volume V contains:

  • Theophanes Continuatus
  • Chronicles from the circle of Symeon the Logothete (Symeon the Metaphrast)
  • Leo the Deacon

Volume VI contains:

  • Michael Psellos or Psellus
  • Kekaumenos’ Strategikon
  • John Skylitzes
  • Scylitzes Continuatus
  • Nikephoros Bryennios the Younger
  • Anna Komnene

The Latin Writers’ Series:

  • Introductory list of materials (Slavica issue 123) Materiały do bibliografii do łacinskiej serii testimoniów najdawniejszych dziejów Słowian (“Materials for the Bibliography to the Latin series of the testimonies of the oldest histories of the Suavs”)
  • Volume I (Slavica issue 139) Starożytność. Pisarze najdawniejsi (“Antiquity, the oldest writers”)

Both of these are available online.

For individual regions you can find lots of Suav mentions in (among many other sources):

  • Monumenta Poloniae Historica (Pomniki dziejowe Polski)
  • Regesta diplomatica nec non epistolaria Bohemiae et Moraviae
  • Codex Diplomaticus Regni Croatiae, Slavoniae et Dalmatiae
  • Monumenta Germaniae Historica
  • Monumenta Boica (Bavaria)

Copyright ©2020 jassa.org All Rights Reserved

August 3, 2020

Fontes Series on Various Ancient Religions

Published Post author

The Meyer Fontes on the religion of the Suavs is but a part of a larger set of publication of sources on religious writing. This is the Fontes historiae religionum ex auctoribus graecis et latinis (collectos subsidiis Societas Rhenanae promovendis litteris. It came out over 1920-1939 edited by A. Marcus, E. Weber, Carl Clemen, Theodor Hopfner, Karl Heinrich Meyer, Hans Zwicker and Bernhard Breloer (think I got all of them).


Fasc. 1

Fontes historiae religionis Persicae (1920)


Fasc. 2

Fontes historiae religionis Aegyptiacae (1922-1925)
(in five parts)

This “contains all known descriptions of and refer­ences to Egyptian religion in the classical authors, both Greek and Latin, from Homer to the mid-Byzantines.”


Fasc. 3

Fontes historiae religionis Germanicae (1928)


Fasc. 4

Fontes Historiae Religionis Slavicae (1931)


Fasc. 5

Fontes historiae religionis Celticae (1934-1936)
(in three parts)


Fasc. 6

Fontes historiae religionum primitivarum, praeindogermanicarum, indogermanicarum minus notarum (1936)


Fasc. 7

Fontes historiae religionum indicarum (1939)


Here are some examples of Germanic religious tradition as listed by Karl Clemens in his Fontes historiae religions Germanicae (see Fasc. 3 above).


  • C. Iulius Caesar
  • Strabo
  • C. Velleius Paterculus
  • P. Papinius Statius
  • P. Cornelius Tacitus
  • Sex. Iulius Frontinus
  • C. Suetonius Tranquillus
  • Plutarchus
  • Appianus
  • Clemens Alexandrinus
  • Cassius Dio
  • Ammianus Marcellinus
  • Claudius Claudianus
  • Eunapius
  • Epistola concilii Aquilensis (a. 381 habiti) ad Gratianum et Valentinianum et Theodosium imperatores
  • Aurelius Augustinus
  • Orosius
  • Sozomenus
  • Apollinaris Sidonius
  • Lex Salica
  • Leges Burgundionum
  • Ennodius
  • Concilium Aspasii Episcopi metropolitani Elusani
  • Jordanes
  • Procopius
  • Agathias
  • Gregorius Turonensis
  • Gregorius I. papa
  • Baudonivia
  • Lex Ribuaria
  • Concilium Clippiacense
  • Concilium sub Sonnatio episcopo Remensi
  • Chronicae quae dicintur Fredegarii scholastici
  • Ionas Segusiensis
  • Edictus Rothari
  • Origo gentis Longobardorum
  • Lex Visigothorum
  • Leges Longobardorum a Grimowaldo additae
  • Poenitentiale Theodori
  • Lex Alamannorum
  • Lex Baiuwaiorum
  • Leges Liutprandi
  • Poenitentiale Egberti
  • Daniel episcopus Vintoniensis
  • Gregorius II. papa
  • Beda Venerabilis
  • Gregorius III. papa
  • Concilium germanicum
  • Indiculus superstitionum et paganiarum
  • Zacharias (papa)
  • Vita Eligii
  • Vita Amandi
  • Vita Landiberti episcopi Traiectensis vetustissima
  • Bonifatius
  • Willibaldus
  • Carolus Magnus
  • Concilium Neuchingense
  • Alevinus
  • Synodi Britannicae
  • Annales regni Francorum
  • Paulus Diaconus
  • Pseudo-Bonifatius
  • Vita Vulframni
  • Vita Barbati
  • Excerptum ex Gallica historia
  • Chronicon Laurissense breve
  • Wettinus
  • Eigil
  • Nennius
  • Ermoldus Nigellus
  • Poenitentiale Pseudo-Theordori
  • Vita Willehadi
  • Vita Lebvini (qui s. VIII. fuit) antiqua
  • Altfridus
  • Pasio Kiliani martyris Wirziburgensis
  • Lex Frisionum
  • Hincmarus Remensis
  • Rudolfus monachus Fuldensis
  • Rimbertus
  • Notkerus Balbulus
  • Poenitentiale ecclesiarum Germaniae (Corrector)
  • Poenitentiale Arundel
  • Widukindus
  • Thietmarus Merseburgensis episcopus
  • Vita Walarici abbatis Leuconaensis
  • Cnutonis regis gesta
  • Wolfherius
  • Adam Bremensis (portions here)
  • Chronicon Fani Sancti Neoti
  • Miracula S. Mathiae
  • Wilhelmus Malmesbiriensis
  • Gesta abbatum Trudonensium
    • (…ex villa nomine Inda… !?)
  • Gesta Herwardi
  • Saxo Grammaticus

Copyright ©2020 jassa.org All Rights Reserved

August 2, 2020